Surprise! Baldwin-Whitehall Maintains Tax Line

'I'm willing to bite it this year.' - school board member Kevin Fischer

In an unexpected move, the Baldwin-Whitehall School Board shot down a recommendation by B-W School District administrators to .

Instead, a new 2012-13 budget plan adopted by the school board at its meeting on Wednesday night keeps 's taxes at a rate of 23.40 mills for at least another fiscal year.

And while votes on both budget plans were split—7-2 against raising taxes and 6-3 in favor of no increase—board members were unofficially unanimous in asserting that the district will eventually see its first tax increase since 2006-07. And that increase could be a large one sometime soon.

"We either do it today, or we do it tomorrow (next year or the year after)," said board member Kevin J. Fischer, who voted on the side of no tax increase on Wednesday.

As causes for a future increase, Fischer and other board members have cited variables like reductions in public education funding at the state and federal level and large increases in expenses related to employee benefits, such as a 43-percent jump in employer contribution to the Public School Employees' Retirement System (PSERS).

"If you want to maintain what you have, you have to pay," Fischer said. "I will not dig into programs."

Nevertheless, on Wednesday, he conceded, "I'm willing to bite it this year."

Even with a 0.5-mill increase, Baldwin-Whitehall would have had to dip into its fund balance—the budgetary surplus that the school board has been accumulating—in order to offset its final expected 2012-13 expenses of $59,744,709. The amount that would have been taken out of the fund balance was $638,985, but that will now be increased to $1,359,985 in order to make up for no tax increase.

"We are depleting our funds," argued board President John B. Schmotzer after voting 'yes' on a 0.5-mill increase and before voting 'no' on no tax increase.

Board member George L. Pry joined Schmotzer in both of those losing efforts. Diana Kazour also voted against no tax increase, but she voted against a 0.5-mill increase, as well.

"We need the half-mill increase to maintain the financial stability of this district," Schmotzer said, pointing out that the increase would still keep Baldwin-Whitehall's rate below what it was in 2006-07 (24.61 mills). "This school district has not raised taxes since the 2006-07 fiscal year. We have held taxes, and in fact, lowered taxes three years in a row.

"That's a pretty strong statement and a credit to this board."

Added Pry, in regard to pulling even more money from B-W's fund balance, which has been instrumental in helping the district to maintain a , "I don't believe this is the time to rob the piggy bank."

Dr. Randal A. Lutz, who will become the district's head superintendent on July 1, called the administration's recommended budget "the right thing to do" and "the responsible thing to do."

But after the recommended budget failed on Wednesday, board member Nancy Sciulli DiNardo proposed the successful no-tax-increase alternative, with more fund balance money being used.

Still, Sciulli DiNardo hinted at what the future might hold.

"I'm not entirely convinced that half a mill is going to solve our problem (anyway)," she said.

Added board member Larry Pantuso, who said that raising taxes will eventually happen, "There are a lot of unknowns yet."

The B-W School District's 23.40 millage rate equates to $2,340 per year for anyone with a property valued at $100,000 (land and building value combined). (Click here to calculate your individual taxes.)

Schmotzer reminded the public on Wednesday that Allegheny County reassessments that have raised property values (starting in 2013) in ,  and  will cause B-W to adjust its 2013-14 millage rate so as to remain revenue neutral. Read .

Board member Nancy Lee Crowder said that raising the district's millage rate is not a good message to send to taxpayers during this time of assessments uncertainty.

Check back with the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch later on Thursday for more odds and ends from Wednesday night's school board meeting, including information on a number of , that led to the district's final budget number.


Follow the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch on Facebook and Twitter.

Sign up for the daily Baldwin-Whitehall newsletter.

Jean Smith June 14, 2012 at 12:40 PM
Let see in 2012, Baldwin Whitehall School District was ranked 219 in Pennsylvania. Lets see how far it drops next year after we created 2 new Dean of Students positions. When they deplete the money that the school district has in surplus then they will hit us with a 1 ml to 2 ml increase in taxes.
Fighting Highlander June 14, 2012 at 04:15 PM
Jean, you are beating a dead horse regarding the Dean of Students position. The middle school had a structure of a principal and 2 vice principals for years and now they have a principal, vice principal and dean of students position. I am not sure of the salary between the two, but I am sure that the district has benefited at least money wise from this change. The high school also had a Dean of Students prior to the current person in this position.
Sasafras Jackson June 14, 2012 at 04:22 PM
As long as everyone in the Boro remains safe, I support this decision by the board. The Dean of Students position will be necessary if, when the time comes, they act appropriately. When is Community Day this year?
Robert Edward Healy, III June 14, 2012 at 04:43 PM
Sasafras, Baldwin (Borough) Community Day is complete, but Whitehall Borough Community Day is scheduled for Saturday, Aug. 25. There is no Baldwin Township Community Day.
Sasafras Jackson June 14, 2012 at 04:56 PM
Thank you, Robert. I hope that you are having a nice summer.
Robert Edward Healy, III June 14, 2012 at 05:00 PM
Baseball and warm weather. What's not to like?! Likewise :)
JustMe June 14, 2012 at 05:43 PM
Yes Fighting Highlanders we need to get rid of custodians, nurse, and teachers to pay for 2 Deans of Students. Jobs that the Vice Principle are suppose to do. Peter Wagner, who had been a permanent substitute, is now the new dean of students at the high school and also one of our coaches. He also said that the wants the job of Athletic Director, which I see given to him in the near future.
JustMe June 14, 2012 at 05:47 PM
Whitehall swimming pool is a great way to cool down after a long day at work
Jean Smith June 14, 2012 at 05:50 PM
Thank you Justme
ResidentTaxpayer June 14, 2012 at 05:58 PM
My family will be out of here by that time as we plan on leaving this district. Our kids did not get the education that we paid our high school taxes for. One who attends CCAC was told (and I was a witness) that Baldwin does not properly prepare high school students for college, at least not the students they see. Guess BW doesn't feel it is important for that ... they care more for the "gifted" students and their futures.
ResidentTaxpayer June 14, 2012 at 06:05 PM
What? Dean of Students? We DO NOT need any Dean of Students. The principals at the high school are not overburdened that they need the help of a Dean of Students. Good God! Have you ever had any dealings with any of the principals? When Keruskin was there, that was like dealing with a clown. His office was informed of things that were going on in the parking lots, especially at dismissal. His office was informed of the smoking on the grounds and on the property (house) next to the high school parking area. People were complaining, rightly so. They were littering, loitering, etc. and quite verbally abusive to anyone who dared to tell them to move or even look at them cross eyed. So, Keruskin had to come out to monitor on the corner to keep the lovely kiddies from littering, loitering, etc. One day up there, in ear range, I overheard him saying that this is not something he should be doing. Really? Really? His job is to oversee everything in that school and that is what he was overpaid to do. That is what those principals are there to do. We do not need any created positions for our school directors (or former directors) to give as favors or payments to their other political friends/families. ELIMINATE THE DEAN OF STUDENTS POSITION!
Robert Edward Healy, III June 14, 2012 at 06:06 PM
Staff Cuts, Furloughs Help Baldwin-Whitehall Balance its Budget: http://patch.com/A-vhjS
Michael Dobs June 14, 2012 at 07:05 PM
If I'm correct the 2 dean of students positions, were a reduced pay position( not making the $ a VP they replaced made) it was a way to get two football coaches in the spots without their principal papers. Most quilfied teachers with their papers did not apply as they were over quilified and under paid for a dean position. 2 subisitute teachers would have a huge pay raise. But it did save the district money! If I remember correctly Mr. Healey did a article this past year about how they got big pay raises?!?! So now where was the district saving money by having under qualified people take top jobs?
Robert Edward Healy, III June 14, 2012 at 07:25 PM
Michael, can you refresh my memory?
JustMe June 14, 2012 at 07:39 PM
Resident Taxpayer, I agree with you there and have heard that from other parents that have children in college. My daughter is now at PA Learners Online Regional Cyber Charter School . http://www.palearnersonline.com/A1/index.html At their open house they had quite a few residents from Baldwin Whitehall who were signing their children up. My daughter says teachers don't teach, drugs are being passed around left and right in the school, students are doing the unthinkable in the stairwells during class. They smoke in the bathrooms during class. Students are selling drugs, smoking in the parking lots, over front of the house by the guards gate. I wish we had in place school vouchers in Pennsylvania and could use them to send our students to any school. When I was up at the school in May to sign papers for my daughters school records to be sent to the school she will be attending next year, they tried to talk me into using a Cyber School though the school district. I'm just sorry that 100% of my taxes won't be going to the Charter School that I choose, but Baldwin Whitehall gets to keep 20% of my tax money. There are many good Cyber and Charter Schools in Pennsylvania with high academic standards. My nephew also was a full time Perm Sub for Baldwin Whitehall School District and he quit because he says Administration is lacking in educating our children.
Michael Dobs June 14, 2012 at 08:10 PM
Did oh not do an article on pay raises for the dean about 3 months ago?
Robert Edward Healy, III June 14, 2012 at 08:11 PM
I can't recall. So many stories, so little brain space! Do you have a link?
Michael Dobs June 14, 2012 at 08:16 PM
I can't find it either... Must be wrong.
Robert Edward Healy, III June 14, 2012 at 08:54 PM
'Pay to Play,' Promotions & Other Leftovers from a June 13 B-W School Board Mtg.: http://patch.com/A-vhJq
AnotherResident June 14, 2012 at 11:33 PM
JustMe .... I want to agree with what you stated above .... I have a son who graduated from Baldwin High School a few years back. When he went to CCAC he had to take a test to see where he was with math and english so that they could place him in the correct classes for his abilities. One of the counselors told me that the students from Baldwin are so behind in what they should have had in high school with regard to math and english. Unbelievable. They come out of that school and didn't even get the basic education that they were sent there for, for which we pay dearly with our hard earned (some of us anyway) tax dollars and which they deserve and need. While my son was at the high school I heard from him and friends about the drugs, the teachers who knew who had them, the smoking, the destruction of new fixtures in the rest rooms, the way students would leave the school during the day, the perverted security guard, the other security guards who had certain students they let get away with anything, the way the office staff treated some students, the students who would start fights and nothing happened, the students who were threatened ... shall I go on? I do not have anything good to say about the high school except that I thank God my son made it out of there in one piece and is thriving at CCAC no thanks to the principals, dean of students, teachers, security, or support staff at the high school. I would advise charter schools to anyone who cares about their kid.
Steve June 15, 2012 at 02:56 AM
Michael you are correct about a Dean of Student getting a salary adjustment. If you go to the school board minutes from February 8th, Action Item 11.4 was for Salary Adjustment for Mike Voelker, Dean of Students at Harrison which goes into effect July 1, 2012, which passed with a 7-1 vote. The district gave raises out earlier this year to certain administrators, but are now cutting employment for others. Administrators should not have been given raises earlier this year. It's not just BW that is messed up like this either. Typical give to those making the big bucks and hit the little guy who really needs the job.
NB resident June 15, 2012 at 09:55 PM
Sounds like next year we are going to get a 1 mil increase. Should have just bit the bullet and raised the taxes now, seems like they are avoiding the inevitable
Jean Smith June 16, 2012 at 02:54 AM
NB resident, I see a big tax increase next year unless they plan on cutting more programs that educate our students. When will they give them selves another raise? It is our students that are being hurt. When they take college entrance test, they are so far lacking in education that they need to spend 3 years at CCAC instead of 2 to make up for things that they should of learned in high school.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something