B-W's Eligibility Policy Actually Stricter than PIAA's

PIAA policy only requires passing grades in any four full-credit subjects.

The 's new policy of holding students to strict academic eligibility requirements for extracurricular activities is even stricter than originally reported, the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch learned on Friday—two days after the policy was debated at length during a B-W School Board meeting.

The policy (No. 122), which goes into effect on Sunday and calls for district students in grades 7 through 12 to achieve a 70 percent or higher in English, mathematics, science or social studies (core subjects), was called "consistent" with the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association (PIAA)'s guidelines on Wednesday. However, further research into those guidelines shows otherwise.

In a story that covers part of Wednesday's school board meeting, the B-W Patch , "The PIAA—that's the requirement to participate in sports. We didn't have a similar requirement to participate in any other activity, so the recommendation to the board was to make it (Policy 122) consistent.

"If the board elects to, we can review it and we can change it for activities, but we can't change it for sports because that's a state regulation."

But the PIAA's requirements for participation in sports—listed here on its website—reads only that students "must be passing at least four full-credit subjects, or the equivalent" to be eligible. In other words, instituting a core-subjects aspect is not a PIAA policy but a Baldwin-Whitehall one.

In an email exchange on Friday, Korchnak said, "The PIAA standards do not match what we want for our students. The process is the same; the standard is more rigorous. We simply applied the PIAA process and the district's standards to ALL activities."

District activities include things such as football, softball, soccer, Math League, Drama Club, et al.

The "process" that Korchnak referred to is indeed reflected in both the PIAA's and the B-W School District's policies in that ineligible students will have one week to raise their grades back to acceptable levels. If their grades are not raised sufficiently within that week, those students will continue to be ineligible for extracurricular participation.

B-W Athletics Director Vince Sortino was caught off-guard by the news that his student-athletes would be held to a new, stricter standard.

"Our student-athletes follow the PIAA standards," Sortino said by email on Friday. "The current academic policy that the board is reviewing is for (other) activities and clubs."

When presented with different information, Sortino replied, "How it was explained to me was that the new club policy was to mirror the PIAA policy. That's about all that I know.

"I am not in the loop on this one, and I have not attended any of the board meetings. I am just giving you my opinion as I understand what the policy was intended to be for clubs and activities."

A policy very similar to Baldwin-Whitehall's No. 122 was instituted in the Sto-Rox School District in 2010, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported.

Sto-Rox's Athletics Director Bill Palermo was critical of that policy. (Full story here.)

"It's unfair, and it's ridiculous," Palermo told the Post-Gazette. "We have one volleyball player with a 3.5 grade average but has a D in a core class right now, so she's ineligible? We have a football player with two As, a B and one D in a core class—and he's ineligible. Something is wrong here."


Follow the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch on Facebook and Twitter.

Sign up for the .

Robert Edward Healy, III March 14, 2012 at 05:49 PM
Wow. Has anyone else had this same thing happen?
As the BHS Guidance Supervisor, I warmly welcome this anonymous Band parent to contact me directly if he/she is dissatisfied with the services the Guidance Department is providing. This certainly applies to all parents and students of BHS. I can be reached by phone (412.885.7500 X8071) or email (smchugh@bwschools.net), and I'm happy to meet in person, too. I am eager to have satisfied customers! Additionally, let me provide some accurate information critical to this discussion: Though the policy is specific to "core" classes for the 70%, PE and other "non-core" classes still play an important role as students must maintain an overall 2.0 GPA (all classes factor into that number, including PE), so they should not be disregarded as unimportant. The policy has not yet taken effect; we are in a "trial period" to ensure successful implementation. Lots of meetings are happening so the students are correctly informed. From the beginning, all of the counselors have been well aware of the correct details of the policy. To-date, none of the counselors have met with the Band Director and a Band student to discuss this policy. We should be very careful -on all issues- but, especially on such a "hot button" issue to share accurate information with everyone. The direct approach is always best and my offer stands for all: don't hesitate to contact me anytime!
Robert Edward Healy, III March 14, 2012 at 08:28 PM
Thank you, Stephanie.
Jean Smith March 15, 2012 at 02:00 AM
Every other school district has to go with the 70% on grades but some parents in Baldwin do not think this should apply to this school. Go over to Mt Lebo, Upper St Clair, Bethel Park, South Fayette and for sports and other activities if you don't have a 70% or higher then you can't be in sports, band, drama club, etc. Can't wait till the end of the year when my daughter will see the end of Baldwin and will be in a better school district.
Robert Edward Healy, III March 15, 2012 at 05:02 AM
UPDATE: B-W School Officials Won't Enforce New Eligibility Policy (Yet): http://patch.com/A-r9qr


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »