VIDEO: Martin Schmotzer Returns to B-W School Board

... but not before a brief shouting match.

Schmotzer Back on Board

The Baldwin-Whitehall School Board chose a familiar face on Wednesday night as its newest member—Martin Michael Schmotzer of Whitehall Borough.

Schmotzer, whose term in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives ended on Nov. 30, replaces his brother, John B. Schmotzer, who resigned from the school board in November for personal reasons.

The board voted, 5-3, to select Martin Schmotzer after board Second Vice President Diana Kazour motioned to appoint him. First Vice President Kevin J. Fischer seconded that motion.

Board members Larry Pantuso, Nancy Lee Crowder and Tracy Macek cast the "no" votes, but they weren't enough to offset "yes" votes from board President Nancy Sciulli DiNardo and fellow board members Ray Rosing, George L. Pry, Kazour and Fischer.

Martin Schmotzer has been a publicly elected B-W School Board member in the past and was most recently on the board in 2011.

There were nine total applicants for the school board vacancy, Sciulli DiNardo said before asking for nominations.

Crowder nominated Karen Brown for the position, and Macek nominated Richard J. Kirsch.

Brown failed to earn the appointment by receiving only one "yes" vote—from Crowder.

Voting for Kirsch never happened, as Martin Schmotzer received the necessary five votes before that came to pass.

(SEE: All 9 Names in Running for B-W Board Vacancy)

Sciulli DiNardo-Crowder Exchange

Before nominating Brown for the vacancy, Crowder attempted to describe that woman's qualifications, but she was eventually cut off by Sciulli DiNardo.

"I have reviewed each and every application as instructed to do so," Crowder said. "When there's an open seat on the board, it allows this board to pick a person who might not even consider running in an election. It should not be about appointing our friends; it should be about appointing the best person for the job.

"However, with that being said, there are people that applied that have been on this board or ran in previous elections. And I appreciate that, because sitting on this board is a thankless job at times. Running in campaigns is another one.

"You please some of the people some of the time, but you will never please all of the people all of the time.

"I only know this candidate (Brown) from reading her application and résumé. She is and has been an educator for many years. I think with all of her experience in the field of education ... "

At that point, Sciulli DiNardo interrupted.

"Mrs. Crowder, do you have a nomination?" she asked.

"Yes, I'm getting there," Crowder responded.

"OK, can you get there?" Sciulli DiNardo asked.

"But I'd like you to know why I'm nominating her," Crowder said.

"It's really not necessary," Sciulli DiNardo said. "Make a nomination. Have somebody second it, and we'll (something, inaudible)."

"Alright, I nominate Karen Brown," Crowder said.

Macek seconded.

(Nancy Crowder Finishes School Board Statement)

Shouting Match, Name-Calling

Before Martin Schmotzer swore in to his new post,  who was in attendance at Wednesday's board meeting, stormed out of the meeting room.

Kalwarski said, "You're sick my ass" on her way out of the room. (Martin Schmotzer said in March 2011 that he was suffering from two forms of cancer.)

Sciulli DiNardo responded, saying, "Mrs. Kalwarski, you're not gonna be welcome here anymore using that vulgarity."

Kalwarski responded, "Excuse me; I'm a taxpayer and ... " before Sciulli DiNardo shouted over her.

"I don't care who you are," Sciulli DiNardo said. "This is a board room, and you'll conduct yourself as a lady.

"You're out of order."

Responded Kalwarski, "No, you are. You're a joke."

Martin Schmotzer then said "white trash" as he walked across the front of the room. His comment was loud enough for the student board representatives section and the first two rows of the audience to hear it.

Closing Comments from Sciulli DiNardo

Sciulli DiNardo used board member comments time on Wednesday to speak of her duties as board President, a position that she took on Dec. 5.

"This is my first time running a voting meeting," she said, "so I apologize if I seem a little nervous and a little bit naïve and not so knowledgeable about how it's different sitting in this seat. And I've also lost a lot of my voice sitting here.

"But I am gonna tell you this: My focus has always been, when I came on this board, educating these kids and doing what's right for children and for taxpayers.

"We will debate on this board, we will be angry at each other on this board, and we are adult enough to leave here and respect one another as individuals.

"What I will not allow this room to turn into is a circus. You wanna not like me? That's fine. You wanna not like anybody on this board? That's fine, too. You don't wanna like the administrators we hire. That's your prerogative, as well.

"You will not come in this room, though—you will not take a mic—(and) you will not insult any of these board members. You will not insult our employees. You're not gonna do it.

"I apologize for what happened earlier in this meeting (shouting match), but I will not apologize for keeping order and trying to keep order. And I'm not gonna have any one of these board members disrespected.

"We are not into torture, and sometimes, we are tortured sitting up here. So, I'm not gonna have it.

"And I have children in this room. They're children. And I'm not gonna have an adult swearing at me or anybody else here. So, I hope that, everybody, we can be respectful here. We can agree to disagree. That's fine.

"But we have to be adults, and we have to be examples."

Interview with Schmotzer

After Wednesday's meeting adjourned, Martin Schmotzer was asked about his motivation for coming back to the school board.

"Just to serve," he said. "I was surprised there was an opening. I did not seek it originally. I was called by a number of board members to apply, and I really thought and prayed about it very long. I applied on the last day.

"But I'm willing to commit the year. I see the inexperience of the board. I know the issues facing the children and the taxpayers, and I think all my experiences, especially the last eight months up at the state House, is a great experience to come back and serve on a local school board."

Read through other Baldwin-Whitehall School Board items here.

And check back with the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch on Thursday for more news from Wednesday night's school board meeting.


Follow the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch on Facebook and Twitter.

Sign up for the daily Baldwin-Whitehall newsletter.

NE12Ukid December 15, 2012 at 10:12 PM
Good for you, Brad.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:04 PM
What is this welcome home Marty statement?
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:13 PM
He must be of the "part of the royal bloodlines" in Baldwin-Whitehall. Where it is who you know instead of the best qualified. Musical chairs of the same names over and over. There are other people in the community, and he calls others a nasty name showing just what he thinks of us. Especially when she was telling the truth. Those on the board knew of his background and theft, yet callously voted for him anyway.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:15 PM
And a Schmotzer daughter on the Student board representatives, to boot. Students see that, too and are not stupid.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:23 PM
That is exactly what these people are, bullies. They will raise their voice, and give you zero respect for what you believe, none. They are appalling and disgusting excuses for human beings.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:27 PM
How could he be surprised. Just another lie.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:28 PM
They ought to out the story of Marty's theft in the school newspaper.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:29 PM
He needed punishment. It would set him straight.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:39 PM
He had to hurl the personal insult for someone telling the truth.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:44 PM
She was rude to Nancy, a fellow school board member, from what I have read,, treating her worse than a potted plant.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 05:54 PM
Thank you.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 06:01 PM
So Marty expunged it from his records, so what. That he was removed is still a fact.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 06:06 PM
Nixon won elections, too.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 06:09 PM
I use my real name, and am not an idiot.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 09:54 PM
An filled out application and resume on 2 pieces of paper do not define a person.
Tom Barchfeld December 16, 2012 at 10:02 PM
Brad, since you like to mock and ridicule, lets meet face to face. So when you try to mock and ridicule me to my face, you will found out what will happen to you.
Barry Moreland December 17, 2012 at 06:19 AM
Tom that is a serious threat, I think you need to be careful what you post on this message board. Robert, you need to take control here, your journalistic integrity and professionalism are starting to fade with each accusation that you allow to be placed on this thread. I would like point out that Marty Schmotzer was CHARGED and not convicted of a crime, thus, if you were true Patriots and bought into the legal system you would restrain from implicating this man as a criminal, when the legal system has cleared him of all charges.
Tom Barchfeld December 17, 2012 at 11:26 AM
Barry, Brad made comments I did not like and felt I had to respond. Brad should not have made those comments. Marty Schmotzer plead guilty to the theft and was also removed from his position, proving he was unfit for the job. He was never punished, stealing $50,000 from the taxpayers, so he has learned nothing from his wrongdoing.
Tom Barchfeld December 17, 2012 at 12:11 PM
Marty Schmotzer did not face the correction he needs.
Tom Barchfeld December 17, 2012 at 12:31 PM
He has said this school board is inexperienced. Yet was surprised there is an opening. This shows he was paying attention to the school board closely by who was on it, and then is surprised of an opening???? Really????????
bd December 17, 2012 at 12:55 PM
Barry - Nice words but the majority of people know that Martin Schmotzer admitted to taking the taxpayers' money and improperly using it for gambling debts and to pay his housekeeper. It was in the papers. He negotiated a deal to keep from getting jail time. While he may never have been "convicted," he is guilty of doing the deed. People on this board know this and no legal technically will ever trump common sense.
bd December 17, 2012 at 12:58 PM
Right you are, Tom. He was supposedly surprised that his brother quit the board. We are supposed to believe that poppycock? Too funny.
Tom Barchfeld December 18, 2012 at 05:19 AM
Phone calls were made by members of the board to Marty Schmotzer asking him to apply. Clearly they already made up their minds before knowing the other candidates.
NE12Ukid December 18, 2012 at 01:28 PM
Tom Barchfeld 5:02 pm on Sunday, December 16, 2012 Brad, since you like to mock and ridicule, lets meet face to face. So when you try to mock and ridicule me to my face, you will found out what will happen to you. ```````````````` ``````````` Our group is cancelling our plans to join this man at Panera's on the 22nd for information and planning. Threats such as the one above should not be ignored. They can be a sign of very troubled behaviors which could lead to violence, of which we choose not to participate in any way.
Tom Barchfeld December 18, 2012 at 02:55 PM
NE12Ukid, you are not part of the group of people here who have made posts about Marty Schmotzer. And about Brad, it is just that I do not like being mocked and ridiculed, no one would. Mocking and ridiculing someone to their face is not the same as sitting at your computer making mock and ridicule posts. It was meant to teach Brad a lesson. The meeting is still on at this point to those who feel about the situation as I do. And I noticed how Nancy Crowder said that choosing a school board member is not about selecting your friends before she was cut off. I wonder why she would say that? She and we all know that is obviously happening, other wise she would not have said it, and it is corrupt, since the other candidates are being ignored. The process of appointing another school board member is an important one. I think more time should be taken for that. The process seems to have been short circuited.
Jon Wain December 18, 2012 at 02:58 PM
" White Trash " a member of Baldwin Whitehall School board (MARTIN SCHMOTZER ) calls a female member of the audience white trash .Yes that's who I want to see on the board making decisions on our childrens education and morals.I'm in favor of rallying everyone to attend these meetings and demand Mr.Schmotzer publicly apoligize to Miss Kalwarski. She to was out of line but she does not represent Baldwin Whitehall school district. And Mrs. Crowder you just keep pushing on. I admire someone who stands alone and refuses to jump under the blankets.
Robert Edward Healy, III December 19, 2012 at 03:11 PM
Nancy Crowder Finishes School Board Statement: http://patch.com/A-0zWy.
bd December 19, 2012 at 03:30 PM
Jon - You are right. In fact, I thought this school district had an anti-bullying policy in place. Does this not pertain to board members or those appointed by the school board? What kind of example is this setting for the students? I guess rules only apply to minority board members and not the majority.
Concerned Whitehall Citizen January 30, 2013 at 11:53 PM
Marty was guilty as sin. He plead guilty in federal court (http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1129&dat=19990724&id=TSQxAAAAIBAJ&sjid=F3ADAAAAIBAJ&pg=3239,1372143). He later got off on a technicality, Doesn't make him innocent. He once bragged about his best freind being chief of staff foe Rendell. With political ties like that, is it any wonder he got off.
Kevin Phillifent November 17, 2013 at 02:06 PM
It's disgusting that Marty has so much power over this school district and that no one has the courage to tell him no. He should have been removed from his position for calling a taxpayer "white trash." What a great example he sets. It's nice to know that we have a criminal running our district.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something