LISTEN: School Board Member's Loud, Colorful Speech Rouses Audience

Kevin Fischer is not a fan of teachers union spokesman Butch Santicola.

Caution: This report (and accompanying media) contains language that some may find offensive.

Baldwin-Whitehall School Board member Kevin J. Fischer reacted harshly at a board meeting on Wednesday night to a news release issued recently by The Pennsylvania State Education Association (PSEA).

In that release—most of which is —PSEA spokesman Butch Santicola said, "The Baldwin-Whitehall School Board just thumbed their noses not only at their teachers ... they also thumbed their noses at the taxpaying residents of  and the students of the district."

Santicola was referring to the school board's decision not to address a labor proposal from the Baldwin-Whitehall Education Association (teachers union) that would have saved the district, as the news release claims, $1.5 million over the next five years.

But B-W Superintendent Dr. Randal A. Lutz said that the union's offer included stipulations, , that were too risky for the board to accept.

During board member comments time on Wednesday, Fischer explained why he and his fellow board members decided not to address the union's proposal and took serious umbrage with Santicola's assertion that the board "thumbed their noses" at anyone.

With his voice raised at times throughout his speech and with his fist sometimes pounding his desk, Fischer said that the union's offer should have included at least a one-year wage freeze in alignment with what other district employees have already done. Instead, he said, the teachers wanted too much.

"All we wanted was one year," Fischer said. "Join the rest of the group. Take one year; put it in your pocket. Let's move on.

"No, no, (they) come back with this list of demands. And let's remember something, folks: 'Take it or leave it' was basically how they put it to us.

"Quite frankly, folks, this board has never thumbed its nose at the taxpayers. But The PSEA, they just told the taxpayers, 'Bend over.'

"That's what they did. That's what they'll do. Take it to the bank.

"Whoever's out there, tell Mr. Santicola, 'Come to Baldwin-Whitehall.' I'll take a day or two off of my job ... Tell him to come here. We'll walk the streets of Baldwin-Whitehall. We'll take our proposal, and we'll take their proposal to the taxpayers of this community. And I'll bet you a nickel to a dollar what they tell me they wanna have.

"We're not the bad guy. And I challenge him to come to here, walk with me and see who the bad guy is."

Click on the audio recording above to hear Fischer's full speech, which drew applause from some members of the audience.

And check back with the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch throughout Thursday for plenty more from Wednesday's board meeting.


Follow the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch on Facebook and Twitter.

Sign up for the daily Baldwin-Whitehall newsletter.

NE12Ukid September 14, 2012 at 10:41 PM
MLR, may I be so bold as to suggest that you share this letter with your child's great teacher? I'm glad too that your child is having a good school year again. Best to you both.
cc September 14, 2012 at 11:54 PM
How did all the other School District teachers around Baldwin/Whitehall take Pay Freezes yet our teachers put stipulations in. They are just a bunch of greedy people. Our school board did make a big mistake this year in not raising property taxes up a half mil. Next year were going to get slammed with a nice raise on our school taxes.
cc September 15, 2012 at 12:20 AM
MLR - We had a long strike in 2007 when teachers were demanding a 5.5% raise per year and they were on the picket line 70 days. They ended up settling for 4% and 4.5 % the following year an the average pay of a teacher back then was 52,000 a year and weren't paying anything towards health insurance before this. In 2009 they negotiated another contract where they get an annual 4% raise and pay 6.5% toward their medical which comes out to 89 a month for family coverage. This contact is in effect till 2015 How many people who live in the Baldwin/Whitehall school district get a annual 4% pay raise and pay 89 a month towards medical for their families?
Mark Archer September 15, 2012 at 05:19 PM
I am in a union, I am also the son of a union member. With that being said I think teachers all over state need to start making some sacrifices like the rest of us. I respect the job that they do, but it is time to start making some concessions. As for Mr. Fischer's rant. He could have gotten his point across better with a little more professionalism. He left the city a long time ago.
cc September 15, 2012 at 09:52 PM
Mark agree with you, they need to take concessions as all unions do. My late husband was in a union and still get the newsletters and see what they have taking in concessions. I even had to take a freeze on the pension that i'm receiving from them.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »