patching...
Update: Receive Baldwin and Whitehall news in your inbox by subscribing to our daily newsletter ... »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

B-W Schools Will Maintain Nurses, Social Workers Levels

Part 1 of notes from a crowded May 2 school board meeting.

 

Nurse, Social Worker to Stay

One week after hearing a proposal to save money by dropping at least one nurse and one social worker from Baldwin-Whitehall's public schools, B-W School Board President John B. Schmotzer told an audience of about 60 people on Wednesday night that the board has no intention of making those cuts.

"The board has instructed administration to not consider the elimination of a school nurse and also not to consider the elimination of a social worker," Schmotzer said during the board's monthly agenda meeting at the district office along Curry Road.

At a special 2012-13 budget meeting on April 25, district administration presented to the board a number of cost-saving and revenue-generating opportunities that could help bridge the gap of a $1.3-million district budget shortfall and/or prevent a sizable district tax hike—two of those opportunities being staff cuts in nursing and social work.

For example, Baldwin-Whitehall employs the equivalent of five full-time nurses right now, but only three are required under state law that mandates one nurse per every 1,500 students. (The B-W School District has approximately 4,200 students.)

Not every board member was in favor on April 25 of cutting at least one nurse and one social worker, but enough members were in favor of the idea for it to live on for more rounds of budget debate.

However, on Wednesday night, those staff cuts were taken off of the table.

"This board is committed to providing services necessary for our students," Schmotzer said, "and somehow, in some way, shape or form, we will find a way to do that."

Nevertheless, Schmotzer commended district administration for proposing ideas to the board that might seem unpopular.

"Whenever you're in budget talks, you put everything on the table," Schmotzer said, "and everything needs to be considered. And it's up to us (board members) as elected officials to either vote up or vote down in what is in the best interests—not only financially but for the student body.

"And the board felt that the elimination of a social worker and a nurse was not in the best interest of our students."

Check back with the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch later on Thursday for more odds and ends from Wednesday night's school board meeting.

 ---

Follow the Baldwin-Whitehall Patch on Facebook and Twitter.

Sign up for the daily Baldwin-Whitehall newsletter.

Related Topics: Baldwin Borough, Baldwin High School, Baldwin Township, Baldwin-Whitehall School Board, Baldwin-Whitehall School District Office, J.E. Harrison Middle School, McAnnulty Elementary School, W.R. Paynter Elementary School, Whitehall Borough, and Whitehall Elementary School

Brian Rampolla

7:51 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

I could not make the meeting, and of course this board does not deem we citizens important enough to broadcast the meetings like most other progressive districts, so I have to ask anyone who attended: did they provide any budget information to the public in the form of hard copy handouts or screen shots of data they were discussing?

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Robert Edward Healy, III

9:16 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

Brian, they did not. The board is voting next week on whether or not to display the budget to the public.

Jean Smith

9:17 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

How about we drop 2 off the school board and 2 off the administration and save a bundle of money. We don't need all of them.

Reply

Marion

9:38 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

School Board Members are public servants that voluntarily give of their time and receive no stipend.

Reply
Comment_arrow

bd

10:18 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

Marion - While they receive no pay, there are perks with the position. Free entrance to all school district events, private parking, and other small perks. Depending on which faction of the board you are on, there may be fully paid trips to national conventions that the board members attend. I used to believe that board members were public servants but the last 10 years or so of watching the
B-W school board proved otherwise to me. Petty politics is paramount in this school district.

Comment_arrow

Jean Smith

10:28 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

I know School Board Members don't get paid. You should go look at the Budget for School Administration and for School Board members, can't they make concessions there. Every year they add more and more money there but want to cut cost elsewhere.

Ron Kasper

9:41 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

Great consideration must be made for those lifelong homeowners in the communities of Baldwin and Whitehall who are on fixed incomes and currently walking a financial tight rope.
A slight increase in taxes could affect a few but a substantial increase in
taxes could seriously affect more. And as a result the trickle down affect could devalue property values in these communiities and the outcome could be worse
in the end.
Currently these communities are peppered with foreclosures. An increase in taxes could increase this phenomenon which in turn will negatively affect the
property values of these communities.
A dilemma so much more relevant today then yesterday considering the economics of our town, city and country. With wages of many near stagnation and others on fixed incomes and those out of work due to no fault of their own..
The choices are few and the times are tough and decisions have to be made
with common sense, integrity and the least fallout.

Reply

Jean Smith

11:09 am on Thursday, May 3, 2012

All school districts in Pennsylvania are getting less money from the State and all schools in the US are going to be getting less money in Federal. It is a shame that they are cutting budgets to fund schools all over but that is how government is trying to make their budgets work.

There are foreclosures everywhere in the US, most of them were caused by balloon mortgages, people buying what they couldn't afford, loss of good paying jobs. Pennsylvania is actually lucky that the prices in homes haven't dropped over the last 10 years as it has in other states.

I don't like the thought of paying more in taxes either but that something that you should expect with being a home owner every year. I was taught years ago in in Economics that if you pay for everything in cash, minus a home or vehicle as most can't afford to pay cash for these items and not to do impulse buying you end up with more money in your pocket. Took me 2 years to pay off my credit cards and my line of credit from the bank and feel I have more money now than what I was making 10 years ago.

Reply

Brian Rampolla

12:57 pm on Thursday, May 3, 2012

It's great that so many people showed up last night to voice their budget concerns. Everyone should ask themselves, however, how would they have know any details of what was being considered if Bob Healy had not been present at last weeks special budget meeting and provided the information in his article? The answer is no one would have know a thing because this board is deliberately withholding information. That's right, deliberately. The only budget related document available to the public is the draft 12-13 budget from last December. By contrast, I invite people to visit the North Hill School District budget web page at http://www.nhsd.net/adminoffice.cfm?subpage=36569, and review the several summary documents they've provided to their residents. And, by the way, note that they have a budget review committee, and look at this nice little statement under Public Participation: "For those who are unable to attend scheduled meetings. ALL school board meetings are videotaped and can be viewed on the district’s website." All of these methods of providing information to the public, which in turn promotes public participation, are very, very, easy to do and have been suggested many times to this board. So, the fact that the leadship of this board has done absolutely nothing along these lines is part of deliberate effort to prevent the public from being fully informed, which is exactly what they want because it avoids questions they would prefer not to have to answer.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jean Smith

6:07 pm on Friday, May 4, 2012

Brian not only does North Hills School District have their proposed budget on the internet so people in their area can see it, most of the other school districts in the south hills does too. Baldwin is one of the few places that hid theirs till it is passed.

Lets face it, they don't want us to know what is going on till they pass the budget and watch the money go up for School Board and Administrative spending, while they cut money to give our kids a better education.

jjtss

6:05 pm on Thursday, May 3, 2012

The real concern is whenever any home owner hears of increases its always the property owner that cringes because we homeowners know the outcome. We always pay more, but we also have to run our homes on a budget and we just can't afford to let increases happen at the boards leisure. Until everyone pays for taxes and not just homeowners, I'll have this attitude.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jean Smith

6:45 pm on Friday, May 4, 2012

In this day and age not everyone can afford to own a home. The people that own homes and rent them out pay school taxes. Business, Apartment complexes also pay school taxes. People that rent might not have to pay school taxes, but they are being collected on the property that they rent. Also people that rent have to pay local and school taxes.

Michael Dobs

10:07 pm on Thursday, May 3, 2012

The next teachers contract should have a residency clause for teachers... All current teachers are grandfathered in... All new teachers have 6 months from start date. Or have to pay X% of a school tax.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Christina

9:40 am on Friday, May 4, 2012

Michael - My concern with the residency clause is that we would not get the best teachers. We would just get the ones that live in Baldwin or are willing to move here and uproot their whole family. It is more important that we have the most qualified teachers.

JustMe

10:41 am on Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Doesn't matter where the teachers live, Baldwin Whitehall needs to hold teachers accountable for their students test scores.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Robert Edward Healy, III

11:11 pm on Wednesday, May 9, 2012

JustMe, I believe that one of your comments directly alluded to alleged inappropriate activity by a B-W School Board member. I deleted that part of that comment. The rest is as follows: "Marion they might be public servants that volunteer for our district but they do have nice perks."

Reply
Comment_arrow

bd

10:27 am on Thursday, May 10, 2012

Robert - You have got to be kidding. You mean the entire street of Parkvue Drive is off limits for comments?

Leave a comment